Halloween Candy You Ate As a Kid from the 60s 4 Lb. Assortment with Personalized Box Top

Wax Lips, Fizzies, Slo Pokes, Wax Bottles with flavored syrup, Candy Cigarettes, Necco Wafers, Candy Buttons on paper tape, Sugar Daddies, Mary Janes, Chiclets, Zagnut, Chunky, Abba-Zaba, BB Bats, Sen Sen, Chick-O-Sticks, Teaberry Gum, Kits, Sugar Babies, and many more candies from the 1960s… still available after all these years.

Gifts Specialty From Old Time Candy Company

$36.99 Check current price

Party Dogs Personalized Button

Round Party Dogs button can be printed with names or a brief message, finished size 2.25″, each. Ages 3 and up.

Personalized Personalized Buttons From Birthday in a Box

$1.49 Check current price

Cheer Napkins

Each of these packages includes 16 of our Cheer Napkins to perfectly complement your other Cheer party supplies.

This product is made with 30% recycled fiber.

Partyware Themed Partyware Dinner Napkins From Birthday in a Box

$3.49 Check current price

Teen Girl Star Personalized Bag Tag

Each of these 2.5″ x 3.9″ laminated Teen Girl Star Personalized Bag Tags comes with a 6″ plastic lanyard. Use them to personalize your guests’ favor bags or give them out as fun party keepsakes to identify backpacks, sports bags and more. Ages 3 and up. (Each)

Personalized Personalized Bag Tags From Birthday in a Box

$1.99 Check current price

Summer Treats Ultimate Birthday Box

Our Summer Treats Ultimate Birthday Box includes everything you need to throw the perfect party for your little one and 7 guests! Contents include full tableware for 8, a variety of Summer Treats decorations, candles, and fun items for your guests.

Party Kits All Party Kits Ultimate Party Kits From Birthday in a Box

$108.99 Check current price